NewZealandLaw

Caution for investors, startup advisers and board observers

Startup companies often rely on advisers, investors and board observers to help guide their new businesses. This is a good thing, but it carries hidden risk.

If you are in one of these roles, in some circumstances, you can be treated as a director, even if you never formally agreed to the appointment. If this happens, it can expose you to personal liability.

 

Directors vs advisers: What’s the difference?

Directors are responsible for the overall governance and strategic direction of the business.

Directorship also comes with legal compliance under the Companies Act 1993. There are significant consequences for directors if things go wrong.

On the other hand, advisers and board observers typically provide strategic, non-binding guidance for the directors to take into consideration when making decisions.

In theory, this is a clear distinction. The line, however, can become blurred. What matters is what you do in practice, rather than your title.

 

How do people become accidental directors?

This is common in startups, where governance structures are still evolving and roles are often informal. Having said that, this is still a real risk for any company. Courts tend to focus on how you are fulfilling your role as an adviser or observer in practice. Warning signs include:

  • The board of directors regularly following your instructions or directions
  • Being involved in decision-making on the same level as directors, and/or
  • Exercising authority normally reserved for directors.

If these patterns develop, you may be seen as a deemed director.

 

Personal liability

Directors’ duties are personal. If a company gets into financial trouble, the directors are exposed to personal liability, and in some instances may be required to personally contribute to company debts. This risk doesn’t just apply to those formally appointed. If you are treated as a director in substance, you may carry this risk without even realising you’ve taken it on.

 

A risk area

Board observers and startup advisers are particularly exposed because their role sits very close to the line. For example, an observer may:

  • Attend meetings and receive board papers
  • Provide input on strategy or decisions, and/or
  • Represent investor interests.

 

That’s fine, but the risk increases where:

  • You participate in decision-making on significant matters
  • The board tends to follow your recommendations
  • Your role is not clearly recorded as ‘observer only,’ and/or
  • You (or your investor) have significant control or approval rights.

Over time, what starts as ‘advice’ can start to look like decision-making.

 

This is one of those areas where things can drift without anyone noticing. Everyone is acting in good faith, wanting the business to succeed, but the legal position gradually shifts. If you are involved in a startup as an adviser, investor or observer, it’s worth asking yourself:

  • Am I just advising, or am I influencing decisions?
  • Does the board treat my input as optional or as direction?
  • Is my role clearly documented and understood?

Small changes in how you operate can make a big difference.

 

Be careful

Being an adviser or board observer is often valuable and rewarding, and is of great benefit to startups. However, there are real risks with these roles that are not always obvious. If your involvement crosses the line into decision-making or control, the law may consider you as a director, exposing you to all the responsibility and possible personal liability that comes with that title.

It pays to be clear about your role from the outset and to keep checking that your involvement hasn’t crept further than intended. If you’re not sure where that line sits in your situation, it’s a good time to get legal advice to help avoid unintended consequences.

 

DISCLAIMER: All the information published in Fineprint is true and accurate to the best of the authors’ knowledge. It should not be a substitute for legal advice. No liability is assumed by the authors or publisher for losses suffered by any person or organisation relying directly or indirectly on this newsletter. Views expressed are those of individual authors, and do not necessarily reflect the view of Edmonds Judd. Articles appearing in Fineprint may be reproduced with prior approval from the editor and credit given to the source.
Copyright, NZ LAW Limited, 2026.     Editor: Adrienne Olsen.       E-mail: [email protected]     Ph: 029 286 3650 


Modern Slavery Bill

Implications for business

The introduction into Parliament of the Modern Slavery Bill has brought awareness of how modern slavery has manifested itself into New Zealand businesses. Modern slavery can rear its ugly head in a range of ways from forced labour in supply chains, exploitation (or coercion) of workers and various forms of trafficking.

The Bill has also made history as it is the first time a bill has been introduced through Standing Order 288. This allows a Private Member’s Bill to bypass the random ballot (or ‘biscuit tin’) process if it is supported by two-thirds of non-executive MPs.

This Bill was co-sponsored by Labour MP Camilla Belich and National MP Greg Fleming. This bi-partisan effort shows the importance of the Bill not only to our parliamentarians, but also to New Zealand society.

 

What is modern slavery?

Modern slavery is often seen as a global matter and, for many New Zealanders, it probably feels like an issue away from our shores. Unfortunately, this is far from the truth. World Vision currently estimates that the average Kiwi spends around $77 a week on goods linked to various forms of modern slavery.[1] Walk Free’s 2023 Global Slavery Index estimated that in 2021, there were 8,000 individuals on any given day, living in modern slavery in New Zealand.[2]

In a high-profile case in the modern history of slavery in New Zealand, Joseph Matamata was convicted of 13 charges of slavery and 10 charges of human trafficking involving labourers working in orchards. After bringing the labourers to New Zealand with promises of a better life, Matamata retained their income, restricted communication and movement, and used threats of violence to ensure the labourers stayed in their jobs.[3]

The Bill

The Bill is both broad and extensive in defining modern slavery. It is defined as:

  • Crimes already understood in the Crimes Act 1961:
    – Dealing in slaves, as well as debt-bondage or sefdom
    – Dealing in people under 18 for sexual exploitation, removal of body parts, or engagement in forced labour
    – People trafficking, and
    – Coerced marriage or civil union
  • The ‘worst forms of child labour’ under Article 3 of the International Labour Organisation Convention No. 182
  • Trafficking as defined by Article 3 of the United Nations Protocol
  • Forced or exploitative labour
  • Servitude, and
  • Sexual exploitation.[4]

 

Outside of the definition of modern slavery, the Bill requires the Minister to report annually on modern slavery matters, to publish guidance and to direct the Chief Human Rights Commissioner to designate modern slavery as a ‘priority area’ if necessary. The Bill will lead to the creation of a Modern Slavery Statement Register to be publicly accessible. All this will be overseen by the proposed independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner.

 

What does this mean for business?

The Bill currently states that ‘reporting entities’ are required to:

  • Prepare and publish annual modern slavery statements that describe their structure and supply chains
  • Identify modern slavery risks (both real and potential)
  • Outline what steps the entity is taking to deal with the identified risks, and
  • Lodge these statements on the Modern Slavery Statement Register.

A ‘reporting entity’ in the Bill is defined as a business with a consolidated annual revenue that exceeds $100 million. These entities not only refer to New Zealand entities, but also any overseas company carrying on business in New Zealand. These entities can be both public and private organisations, with government agencies also being captured under this regime.

 

How this affects New Zealand businesses

If your business is considered a reporting entity under the Bill, non-compliance with the regime could carry a strong penalty. Offences will be committed if entities fail to comply with their reporting obligations, or if they knowingly make false or misleading statements in their reports. These offences could amount to reporting entities being liable on conviction to a fine of up to $200,000.

From a civil point of view, the maximum pecuniary penalty for a contravening reporting entity is $600,000.

This also imposes personal liability for directors and individuals involved in management. If an offence occurs with the permission, knowledge or presumed knowledge of these individuals, they will be found guilty. This is particularly important if the director or management should have known it was occurring but failed to take reasonable steps to prevent it from happening.

The final important note for businesses is that if they are found to be non-compliant, both the name of the business and the individuals responsible will be published on the Register for three years.

 

Preparing for the Bill to become law

Many affected by the reporting obligations of this Bill may already be familiar with its obligations, considering there are similar laws in other jurisdictions. However, potential ways to prepare for the implementation of the modern slavery legislation in New Zealand could be in the form of preparing policies and governance, reviewing supply and procurement contracts (and being particularly diligent about who your suppliers are), and potentially establishing internal whistleblowing procedures.

Other steps could involve identifying risk factors that may facilitate the exploitation of workers, and developing management plans to mitigate them. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade has a range of specific resources all targeted towards combatting modern slavery.[5]

 

A positive development

This Bill is widely seen as a positive development in New Zealand law. While there may be concerns on the extent of obligations imposed on entities, the benefits to victims undoubtedly outweigh the costs. If you are concerned that this proposed legislation may affect the way you do business, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

[1]  https://www.worldvision.org.nz/about/media/parliamentary-rule-modern-slavery-act-for-nz/

[2] https://www.walkfree.org/global-slavery-index/country-studies/new-zealand/

[3] Joseph Auga Matamata v R [2020] NZHC 1829.

[4] https://www.legislation.govt.nz/bill/members/2026/242/en/latest/#LMS1569519

[5] https://www.mfat.govt.nz/en/trade/nz-trade-policy/combatting-modern-slavery

 

DISCLAIMER: All the information published in Fineprint is true and accurate to the best of the authors’ knowledge. It should not be a substitute for legal advice. No liability is assumed by the authors or publisher for losses suffered by any person or organisation relying directly or indirectly on this newsletter. Views expressed are those of individual authors, and do not necessarily reflect the view of Edmonds Judd. Articles appearing in Fineprint may be reproduced with prior approval from the editor and credit given to the source.
Copyright, NZ LAW Limited, 2026.     Editor: Adrienne Olsen.       E-mail: [email protected]     Ph: 029 286 3650 


Postscript

RMA replacement legislation reported back from select committee

 

On 20 July, the select committee reported back on the Natural Environment Bill and the Planning Bill, that are set to replace the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The committee received 3,204 submissions and heard presentations from 178 submitters.

Whilst key features of the new system have been retained, the select committee recommended some improvements (that the government supports) that will refine and clarify some aspects of the bills.

After feedback from a range of submitters, the timeframe to implement the transition period from the RMA to the two new statutes has been extended from 30 months to 39 months.

The Labour Party has indicated that if it forms a government in November, it will not repeal this new legislation. The party does, however, state that it has some serious misgivings about some aspects, particularly the regulatory relief provisions.

In the meantime, there is some hard work to be done to incorporate the committee’s recommendations and present the bills again to Parliament for a second reading – all before the House rises in September for the 7 November election.

For more information on the Environment Committee’s report go here.[1]

[1]  https://www3.parliament.nz/en/pb/sc/scl/environment/tab report#filterformsearchtarget 

 

Fineprint’s 100th edition!

The eagle-eyed amongst you may have noticed we are publishing the 100th edition of Fineprint. This is not only a significant milestone for any publication, but also an affirmation to all our readers, that Fineprint continues to resonate with you in terms of relevant content.

Established in April 1997, we have moved from two-colour printed hard copy to publishing a full-colour beautifully-designed edition (thank you Mission Hall Creative) as you see today. Over the years, we have shifted from hard copy only, to now mostly publishing electronically. We have moved with the times.

Our biggest thank you goes to you, our readers, who continue to enjoy reading Fineprint and have given us valuable feedback in terms of topics to cover. We will continue publishing interesting, useful and sometimes thought-provoking content that not only covers legal issues, but also the wider business and social communities. If you would like to give us feedback, please email the editor at: [email protected].

Thank you and kia ora.

 

 

DISCLAIMER: All the information published in Fineprint is true and accurate to the best of the authors’ knowledge. It should not be a substitute for legal advice. No liability is assumed by the authors or publisher for losses suffered by any person or organisation relying directly or indirectly on this newsletter. Views expressed are those of individual authors, and do not necessarily reflect the view of Edmonds Judd. Articles appearing in Fineprint may be reproduced with prior approval from the editor and credit given to the source.
Copyright, NZ LAW Limited, 2026.     Editor: Adrienne Olsen.       E-mail: [email protected]     Ph: 029 286 3650 


Over the fence

High Court upholds personal liability on forestry directors for environmental costs

A recent New Zealand High Court decision[1] has reinforced that company directors can be held personally liable for environmental damage caused by forestry operations.

The court determined that the directors of the companies involved should have taken action to clean up the forestry work. Failing to do so resulted in safety concerns: the land was prone to erosion and was steeply forested, resulting in a downstream of left-over woody debris, slash and sediment that was harmful to the environment and could be harmful in a flood.

The appeal affirmed the decision reached in the Environment Court in 2025.

The result of the High Court’s decision means that company directors in the rural forestry sector must take notice of the work completed on site and actively take steps to avoid issues. Directors cannot avoid liability by relying on corporate structures alone.

The directors had a duty to ensure consents and the Resource Management Act 1991 were complied with, and their failure to do so had serious financial consequences for them. As directors may be found personally liable, the culpability and costs for environmental breaches may not be limited to the assets of the company and may have financial implications for the directors personally.

 

Wilding pines: Budget 2026 injection

Wilding pines are self-seeded conifers. These trees can have environmental benefits including providing timber and shelter, storing carbon, decreasing erosion, and improving water and soil when planted correctly.

However, wilding pines can cause issues including invading tussock grasslands or native landscapes, drying out water catchments and raising the risk for wildfires. The impact can differ depending on the area.

To help manage wilding pines, in the 2026 Budget the government committed an additional $79 million to be spent over the next three years on the National Wilding Conifer Control Programme lifting the total committed funding to $109 million. The funding will go towards protecting farmland, water supplies, reducing wildfire risk in affected areas and the protection of native biodiversity.

New Zealand’s pine industry has become one of the country’s most important land uses shaping the economy, environment and rural communities. Managed plantations earn billions in export revenue each year. Wilding pines can jeopardise this.

The funding increase reflects New Zealand’s value for biosecurity protection and forward future-based thinking. Managing the spread of wilding pines will be mitigated through collaborative governance as volunteers, landowners, iwi and community trusts are also committed towards wilding pine control.

 

Rural Roading Resilience investment

Rural roads are relied on by communities, tourists and freight operators; damage to these roads can lead to communities being cut off in severe weather events and a risk to health and safety of those on the road. These roads provide, amongst other things, access for freight, school transport, tourism and emergency access.

The 2026 Budget committed funds to the Rural Roading Resilience project. Its purpose is to strengthen roads rather than continually repairing them once the damage is done. The Budget allocated $400 million towards a package of state highway resilience upgrades.

When severe weather events damage rural roads, access to the wider rural community can be limited until the issues are rectified. Strengthening roads before an issue arises aims to limit the impact of severe weather events on rural communities and to allow freight routes to continue with minimal disruption.

The funding will be used towards improving drainage, slope stabilisation and rockfall protection. It will also fund the development of flood mapping systems and emergency management tools, including hazard maps and evacuation or emergency information. This will help local councils and communities to plan for flood risks. The focus will be on predicted areas of consistent vulnerability. It is hoped better preparation will minimise the long-term costs incurred by taxpayers.

[1] Samnic Forest Management Ltd v Gisborne District Council [2026] NZHC 1880.

 

DISCLAIMER: All the information published in Rural eSpeaking is true and accurate to the best of the authors’ knowledge. It should not be a substitute for legal advice. No liability is assumed by the authors or publisher for losses suffered by any person or organisation relying directly or indirectly on this newsletter. Views expressed are those of individual authors, and do not necessarily reflect the view of Edmonds Judd. Articles appearing in Rural eSpeaking may be reproduced with prior approval from the editor and credit given to the source.
Content Copyright © NZ LAW Limited, 2026.    Editor: Adrienne Olsen.       E-mail: [email protected]      Ph: 029 286 3650