Litigation Lessons from the Top Court ⚖️
If nothing highlights the risks of litigation better, it’s the Supreme Court’s decision this week in Routhan v PGG Wrightson Real Estate Ltd [2025] NSCA 68.
The Routhans bought a dairy farm in 2010, relying on a real estate agent’s claim that the farm produced 103,000 kgMS of milk solids annually. In reality, the property was not capable of reaching that figure. Their farming venture failed, ending in a forced sale in 2020 and a total loss of equity. They sued. The High Court awarded $1.69M. The Court of Appeal cut it to $300K. The Supreme Court has now ruled for $780,500 in a split decision.
It’s a stark reminder that going to court can be a long, expensive, and exhausting road. In many cases, it’s worth exploring other options, like early settlement negotiations, mediation, or arbitration. Settling can save time, money, and a lot of stress.
Thinking about your options? Our litigation and arbitration team at Edmonds Judd is here to help. 🤝
